How we test and score products
The method behind every review and score on Trustbuy.
Last updated:
1. Choosing what to review
We start from what readers are trying to decide: the category, the budget and the typical use. We shortlist products that are widely available in the markets we cover, and include products without an affiliate programme when they belong on the list. Brands cannot pay to be included.
2. Defining criteria before testing
For each category we set the criteria and their weights before we test, so results cannot be bent to fit a favourite. Typical criteria are build quality, performance in real use, ease of use, and value for money.
3. Testing
- Hands-on use in the conditions the product is made for, over a realistic period.
- Measurements where a property can be measured, using the same procedure for every product in a comparison.
- Specifications are taken from the manufacturer and checked against the product we test.
- Where we could not test a product ourselves and rely on research, the review says so clearly.
4. Scoring
- Each criterion receives a score out of 10.
- The overall score is the weighted average of the criterion scores, using the weights set in step 2.
- Every review shows the breakdown, so you can re-weight what matters to you.
5. How we use AI tools
We may use AI tools to help draft or restructure text. An AI tool never publishes anything on its own: every draft is checked, edited and approved by a member of our team before publication. Specifications, prices and measurements come only from the manufacturer, the retailer or our own testing — never from an AI tool — and we do not use AI to write customer reviews or ratings.
6. Keeping reviews current
Prices and models change. We revisit reviews when a product is updated or discontinued, or when readers report a problem, and show the date of the last update at the top of each page.
What never influences a score
- Commission rates or whether a product has an affiliate programme.
- Free samples or loans from brands (a sample is returned or disclosed).
- Requests from brands to change or remove a review.



